Although the Brangelina breakup of 2016 might go down as the most devastating celebrity split in history, we’ve claimed to have lost all faith in love many times before. A little closer to home, here are ten New Jersey celebrity breakups we still haven’t emotionally recovered from.
1. Joe Jonas and Gigi Hadid
Gigi apparently dumped the Wyckoff native in late 2015 after a few months of dating.
2. Brooke Shields and Michael Jackson
Although the Englewood native denies that their relationship was romantic, she told PEOPLE that they went on a few dates and loved one another.
3. Christina Milian and Lil Wayne
The pair broke up earlier this year after reports that Weezy cheated on the Jersey City-born singer.
4. Sammi Sweetheart and Ronnie Magro (maybe)
Now that Jersey Shore is no longer on the air, it’s tough to tell whether this couple is still together. But, when they have broken up in the past, we’ve always been really sad. (We miss hearing “Rahn stahp!”)
5. Frankie Muniz and Hilary Duff
This adorable couple dated when they starred in Agent Cody Banks together in 2003. After dating Wood-Rige’s own Frankie, Hilary briefly saw Shia LeBeouf.
6. Nick Jonas and Olivia Culpo
7. Tara Reid and Carson Daly
The pair was engaged for a short time until the former TRL host decided that his Jersey fiancé liked to party too much.
8. Derek Jeter and Minka Kelly
…and Mariah Carey, Vanessa Minnillo and many others before he married Hannah Davis.
9. Bruce Willis and Demi Moore
Demi and Jersey boy Bruce divorced in 2000, and although the separation was particularly tough on Rumer, they were still able to co-parent their three daughters.
10. Chelsea Handler and 50 Cent
Livingston native Chelsea dated 50 Cent for a while in 2010. Even after they broke up, the rapper described his love for the comedian as “out of control.”